Back to Find food

Official GastroMob Destination · Michiana

Freshieez Pizza

GastroMob approved badge
GastroMob visit

Pizza

24968 County Road 6
Elkhart, IN 46514

Hours
Mon closed; Tue–Wed 4–8 PM; Thu 11 AM–8 PM; Fri–Sat 11 AM–9 PM; Sun noon–6 PM.

Report this place

LET’S GO EAT

What’s happening here

Upcoming tables, events, and entertainment at Freshieez Pizza.

Full GastroMob calendar

Loading confirmed gatherings…

GastroMob CALENDAR

November 2026

November 2026. Select a date to see its full schedule, or an event to open its page. Times in Eastern Standard Time.
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
  • Monthly Mob
  • Share a Table
  • Community event
  • Live entertainment
  • Event table
  • GastroMob event

Times in Eastern Standard Time. Select any gathering for its page.

All upcoming gatherings (0)

Still checking nearby calendars. Start a table.

Own or manage this venue?

Restaurant reviews

Review this restaurant

From the GastroMob Facebook archive

Freshieez

I wanted to drop these pictures from our last mob GastroMob September Mob at Freshieez in Elkhart. It was a good time and we couldn't ask for better hosts. looking forward to GastroMob October Mob at Taqueria Don Chepe in Niles and Gastromob November Mob at Coney Express in South Bend.

Photo shared with Canna Bruce’s Facebook review of Freshieez.
Photo shared with Canna Bruce’s Facebook review of Freshieez.

View the original Facebook post

Valued by 0 members

From the GastroMob Facebook archive

Freshieez

Originally shared on .

Summary of Sandy’s Facebook review: Sandy enjoyed the September GastroMob at Freshieez and recommended the restaurant. She ordered the Lisa Yoder State Farm signature pizza with a cream cheese sauce, bacon, spinach, mushrooms and tomatoes. She liked it, though she would have preferred it more well done as requested. She also described a fun conversation with another patron and his dog Charlie.

View the original Facebook post

Valued by 0 members

From the GastroMob Facebook archive

Freshieez

Originally shared on .

Freshieez we really enjoyed the food!!!!

Photo shared with Jessica Leonardo’s Facebook review of Freshieez.
Photo shared with Jessica Leonardo’s Facebook review of Freshieez.

View the original Facebook post

Valued by 0 members

From the GastroMob Facebook archive

Freshieez

Originally shared on .

Had some great food today! And always fun hanging out with Steve and Brooke!

View the original Facebook post

Valued by 0 members

From the GastroMob Facebook archive

Freshieez

Originally shared on .

I just got home from Freshieez , and I am currently carrying more dairy than I thought the human body could reasonably accommodate. GastroMob September Mob landed at Freshieez in Elkhart today, and this one felt right before we ever took the first bite. Freshieez has built itself around a pretty simple idea. Make things fresh, give people plenty…

Read the full review

I just got home from Freshieez , and I am currently carrying more dairy than I thought the human body could reasonably accommodate. GastroMob September Mob landed at Freshieez in Elkhart today, and this one felt right before we ever took the first bite. Freshieez has built itself around a pretty simple idea. Make things fresh, give people plenty of choices, and be part of the community that keeps the doors open. They make their own dough, cut their vegetables, make their own sauces and offer enough styles of pizza that they seem unwilling to make any pizza feel as though it does not belong. Thin crust, thick crust, pan pizza, Detroit style, New York style, Chicago style and a 36 inch monster appropriately named Tiny. They do not discriminate. If it can reasonably be called pizza, Freshieez is willing to have the conversation. That community piece did not get added later because it made for good marketing. Owner Steve Olinger has said it was a founding principle and was built into the business plan from the beginning. You can see it all over the place. Their pizza boxes showcase other local businesses, their Wall of Fame promotes other small businesses, and they have partnered with the Elkhart Public Library Summer Reading Challenge, including providing 2,000 free pizzas to encourage kids to read. Right there on the wall is the Freshieez Community Giving Tree with one of the simplest, most beautiful ideas imaginable. Need a meal? Take a meal. Got a meal? Leave a meal. That probably helps explain how Freshieez became our September destination. We started with 43 hometown pizza nominees and people came out swinging for their favorites. Freshieez climbed past some very serious local pizza competition and finished on top with more than 470 votes. That was not GastroMob declaring the best pizza in Michiana from a mountaintop. That was hundreds of local people saying, this is our place, go try it. So today we did. Even with the rain, 19 people plus me came through for kickoff. There were familiar GastroMob faces, several new ones, which is always cool to see, and Charlie the dog, who conducted his own independent investigation of everything within smelling distance. Freshieez put out a really nice spread that let us actually explore what they do instead of everybody just ordering the same thing. Different crusts, different styles, breadsticks and enough variety that people could try something outside their normal order. It was less a buffet than a tour of what Freshieez can do. The owner made his way around the room and talked to people, and not just to ask, “What do you want?” He wanted to know what you liked, what you did not like, what you had tried before and what you might want to try next. He was not just filling an order. He was figuring out what somebody might actually enjoy eating. Then we met Tiny. Tiny is their 36 inch pizza, which is a funny name for something roughly the size of a truck tire. Watching that thing come together became part of the event. They stretched an enormous piece of dough across the prep table, tossed it, pulled it, sauced it and started building a massive pizza. Then they invited a kid from our group into the kitchen to help cheese it. There he stood in his GastroMob shirt, cheesing hard as he cheesed up a 36 inch pizza, a diameter nearly as tall as he was, while his dad stood nearby watching. You could see the pride on Dad's face while this completely unexpected core memory was being made. Nobody was just making lunch anymore. I would be willing to bet Freshieez made themselves a customer and a pizza enthusiast for life right there. The next generation of Freshieez regulars may have been born over a bucket of mozzarella. Tiny made its way into the oven.Getting it back out took two grown men and a level of coordination normally reserved for moving appliances. Once it hit the counter and got cut up, the Mob went to work. There was so much food that everybody ate, people went back for more, and plenty of folks still took food home. Then came the dessert deep dish pizzas. People liked the apple, but the blueberry was the one everybody kept talking about. Naturally, we followed all of that with ice cream because after consuming pizza covered in cheese followed by dessert pizza, we became concerned that we had not consumed enough dairy. I am home now, and I can report that concern has been thoroughly addressed. Somewhere between Tiny, the blueberry dessert pizza, the ice cream, the rain outside and conversations bouncing between tables, I noticed something else. Nobody was rushed. Some of us sat there after eating and talked. Nobody hovered because they needed the table, and nobody made us feel like the transaction was complete and our continued presence had become inconvenient. We were allowed to sit there and simply be there. That may sound like a small thing, but it gets pretty close to the reason GastroMob exists in the first place. Food gives people an excuse to leave the house, sit across from somebody, meet somebody they might not otherwise meet and feel like they belong somewhere for a little while. Sometimes fighting social isolation looks a whole lot like sitting around a pizza place longer than necessary. Freshieez understood that. I understand why more than 470 people pushed them to the top of our hometown pizza vote. Freshieez is absolutely a GastroMob destination. They do pizza right, but they do community even better. Remember, today was only the kickoff. September GastroMob at Freshieez lasts all week. If the rain kept you home, if crowds are not your thing, or if today simply did not work, you still have time to go in, try something you normally would not order, ask them what they think you should eat, check out the Giving Tree and be part of GastroMob in your own way.

Photo shared with Canna Bruce’s Facebook review of Freshieez.
Photo shared with Canna Bruce’s Facebook review of Freshieez.

View the original Facebook post

Valued by 0 members
GastroMob history & notes

NOMINATIONS AND VISITS

GASTROMOB HISTORY

Nominated:September 2026
September2026
Selected Destination

Pizza Mob

September kickoff completed; recap and photos on the Michiana chapter page

September2026
Winner · Selected

Pizza Mob

Winner / selected destination

Other2026
Community partner / drop-off

Backpacks for Teachers

Donation drop-off location.