From the community
Yellow Cat Cafe
★★★★ 4/5
GastroMob Share a Table Review: Yellow Cat Café South Bend, Indiana We let the GastroMob Randomizer decide where we were going for breakfast, created a Share a Table, and headed for Yellow Cat Café. Sometimes you just have to let the universe pick the restaurant and see what happens. I'm glad we did. Saturday morning, 10:30. The Yellow Cat Café…
Read the full review
GastroMob Share a Table Review: Yellow Cat Café South Bend, Indiana We let the GastroMob Randomizer decide where we were going for breakfast, created a Share a Table, and headed for Yellow Cat Café. Sometimes you just have to let the universe pick the restaurant and see what happens. I'm glad we did. Saturday morning, 10:30. The Yellow Cat Café is hopping, the coffee is flowing, and somewhere among the wood-paneled walls, assorted signs, cat memorabilia, and a suit of armor with a stuffed cat peeking out of its helmet, breakfast is happening. This place has that wonderful lived-in feeling without looking like somebody hired a decorator to manufacture nostalgia. It's comfortable, unpretentious, and feels a little like sitting at somebody's kitchen counter. Somebody with a rather interesting collection of shit hanging on the walls. We had a table for three, although our entire party hadn't arrived yet. The place was busy, but nobody seemed interested in rushing us along. The staff was friendly, accommodating, and perfectly content to let us settle in. There's a difference between a restaurant that's busy and one that makes you feel like you're in the way because it's busy. Yellow Cat has figured that out. I ordered hot tea and was presented with a wooden chest containing what must have been no fewer than 50 varieties. Fifty! I wanted a cup of hot tea...uhh Black tea? I dunno..so many choices! Then I noticed the collection of hot sauces, easily a hundred or so bottles standing at attention like some kind of spicy little army. There's a culinary collector lurking somewhere back in that kitchen. "Well, we certainly can't NOT have that one." I ordered the Eggs Benedict, one of those dishes that can tell you quite a bit about what's happening in a kitchen. The eggs were poached perfectly, the English muffins had just the right amount of toast to them, and the hollandaise tasted homemade. You can tell when somebody actually gives a bacon about the sauce instead of just introducing hot water to a powder and calling it breakfast. My only quibble, and this is strictly personal preference, is that I'd rather have one nice thick slice of ham than several thin slices. Hardly a crime against breakfast. The farmhouse diced potatoes were nicely browned with a satisfying crunch on the outside. Good stuff. Of course, I had to order a biscuit and gravy. It's one of my measuring sticks for a breakfast joint. Some people judge a restaurant by its coffee, some by its service, and some by whether the silverware matches. I judge them by whether they can make a decent sausage gravy without turning it into wallpaper paste. Yellow Cat passed. The wet flour to dry flour ratio was perfectly acceptable, there was a decent amount of sausage, and the whole thing was perfectly fine. Nothing to write home about, but certainly nothing to complain about either. A respectable showing in the biscuit-and-gravy division. Let's talk about the soup. A while back Jen and I decided soup is breakfast appetizer so I had to try the REUBEN SOUP. What the hell is Reuben soup? That's exactly what I wanted to know when I spotted it on the chalkboard. I love a good Reuben sandwich, but turning one into a bowl of soup sounded like either a stroke of genius or a culinary misdemeanor. Curiosity got the better of my belly, as it frequently does, and I ordered a bowl. ERR. MER. GERD. Ladies and gentlemen, this stuff was magnificent. Creamy, rich, loaded with actual chunks of corned beef, and just enough sauerkraut to give it that unmistakable Reuben character without making you feel like somebody dumped a jar of fermented cabbage into your bowl. The balance was diggity near perfect. Every spoonful tasted like somebody had figured out exactly what makes a Reuben sandwich wonderful and then convinced it to become soup. I went in curious and came out a believer. The Reuben soup was unquestionably the star of my breakfast, and that's saying something considering how well they handled the Benedict. It was one of those wonderful little surprises that reminds me why I enjoy wandering into local restaurants and ordering things I've never tried before. I shall absolutely continue my tradition of having soup as a breakfast appetizer. Society may have questions about that. Society can mind its own damn business. The Randomizer picked the restaurant, Share a Table gave us a reason to get together, and Yellow Cat delivered a fine Saturday morning. That's pretty much the whole idea behind GastroMob. Discover somewhere local, pull up a chair, meet somebody, and enjoy a meal. No elaborate planning required. I'll be back, and there's a pretty good chance my next breakfast will start with another bowl of soup. www.GastroMob.com https://gastromob.com/find-local/yellow-cat-cafe

